About OgreCave and its staff

Christmas Gift Guide 2010 (11/26/10)
PAX East 2010 report (4/9/10)
Christmas Gift Guide 2009 (12/4/09)
Games of the Ninja 2008 (12/5/08)
Christmas Gift Guide 2008 (11/27/08)
Screams from the Cave 2008
Ogres' Choice Awards 2008 (9/12/08)
Christmas Gift Guide 2007 (11/30/07)
Ogres' Choice Awards 2007 (8/17/07)
GAMA Trade Show 2007 report (4/27/07)
Christmas Gift Guide 2006 (11/30/06)
Ogres' Choice Awards 2006 (7/28/06)
Christmas Gift Guide 2005 (11/29/05)
Christmas Gift Guide 2004 (12/10/04)
Night of the Living Gamer
(Halloween RPGs)

Archive highlights
GAMA Trade Show 2008 report, part 2
GAMA Trade Show 2008 report, part 1
Frag Beta Capsule Review (4/14/01)
Battle Cattle Minis Preview (2/28/01)

Convention Report: PAX East 2010
by Lee Valentine

Cave dweller Lee Valentine has ventured forth to the first ever PAX East (Penny Arcade Expo) 2010 in Boston, MA. His observations, revelations, and consternations are below. We invite you to post your comments here.

OgreCave at

PAX East logo


Hello, Cave dwellers – Lee Valentine here with the OgreCave PAX East round up. Let me start by saying that the last console I played for more than a couple minutes is the Sega Genesis, and the last time I spent any significant time in the arcade was in 1990. I do play a handful of PC games, but mostly those are ports of board or card games. I watch a lot of sci-fi TV and play a lot of hobby games, but I am not a regular convention attendee. I'm a hardcore gamer and also a comic geek, but I rarely attend conventions or go to other types of geek gatherings. As a result, PAX East 2010 was something of a system shock for me.

Looking East
As another con attendee observed, PAX East showed some signs of a first year show. At least one game I attended started 40 minutes late. Unwieldy lines for panels sometimes wound in serpentine patterns, and there were some other minor nuisances. That said, for the show's first time at the Boston site, I thought the show was a good one, and there was a lot of value for cost of entry. I would definitely attend again. If I were to describe PAX East with one word, however, it would be "queueing". I started by waiting in line for about 15 minutes to get into the show, then I waited for an hour in a line for a game that was starting very late, and then the game (unbeknownst to me) was going to require me to stand in a queue as part of the game mechanic – I left only shortly after the game started. [Action Castle, in case anyone's curious. –Sven] As a result of not wanting to spend an entire weekend standing in a queue, I only caught a handful of panels and scheduled events.

Never having attended PAX before, I didn't know what to expect in terms of game attendance. Most board and card gaming was played in the form of pick-up games, with notable games like Dominion, Munchkin, Magic: The Gathering and Puerto Rico having scheduled tournaments. The rooms for free-gaming were often filled to the max, and the con could have used more space for these games. Similarly, Wizards of the Coast's Dungeons & Dragons events were overflowing with people who wanted to game but couldn't, and they should have had more tables for events. The con's play space seemed to me to be skewed toward electronic games: handhelds, consoles, PC games, and even '80s arcade classics. However, it was obvious that Boston really could handle a larger hobby game convention than it currently has.

Summoner Wars at PAX EastThere were a handful of hobby game publishers other than the prominently-placed Wizards of the Coast. Colby Dauch's company Plaid Hat Games was out in force pushing Summoner Wars. Colby was showing off some new beta decks for his game, and the one I played was very interesting, superior to the ones I reviewed here at the Cave. Zev Shlasinger's Z-Man Games was demo'ing Dungeon Lords and Wasabi (Wasabi was a blast – thanks Paul and Zev). Asmodee had Cyclades and Claustrophobia. Steve Jackson Games was out in force, pushing Zombie Dice, Cthulhu Dice, Nanuk, and Revolution. I even saw Your Move Games' Battleground being demo'd. Part of the dearth of hobby game companies here was PAX's focus on video games, but part of it had to do with the GAMA Trade Show (GTS) actually overlapping a day with PAX East on opposite ends of the country. The guys from Steve Jackson Game showed intestinal fortitude, by flying from GTS to PAX East, doing both shows as best they could. All the hobby companies present really were doing outstanding jobs supporting their products and doing demo after demo. Most were focusing on allowing hobbyists to play a complete game, while others were in the five-minute pitch mode.

Luke Crane, of Burning Wheel fame, was at PAX East pushing games for Indie Press Revolution and running demos of his own games. He was excited about his latest project called FreeMarket, a.k.a. "Project Donut", a transhumanist RPG that he's been working on with Jared Sorenson (which our own Mike Sugarbaker is fond of discussing from time to time). Luke, an exceedingly friendly guy who loves his products, also has a solid ability to pitch the products of his indie RPG peers. I'm glad I got a chance to talk to him.

Wil W at PAX EastWil Wheaton, once of Star Trek: TNG, also showed the hobby side some love. He looked on while I played Dungeon Lords, and then spent a fair bit of time at the booth with Phil Reed, Will Schoonover, and the gang at Steve Jackson Games. Wil gave a very humorous keynote address which had the main theme that it's OK to be proud of being a gamer geek. My favorite part of the speech was when he conducted an experiment to see how many generations were in the room by using unexplained quotes from games as applause lines. I believe "Shots do not hurt other players" was one I remembered fondly from Gauntlet. There was also "Black Lotus, Dark Ritual, and I summon a Sengir Vampire". The list goes on. Wheaton was basking in the adulation the crowd had for him, for a man who was a proud geek, and yet could comfortably straddle the line between geek culture and the mainstream. Alas, I took a picture of Wil with the folks at SJG, but my camera seems to have eaten the shot.

[Note: The folks at Steve Jackson Games were kind enough to let us use their shot of Wil at the booth, taken by Phil Reed. –Sven]


I've talked about most of the hobby game publishers already, who were in the tabletop gaming area. There were two notable ones in the big Expo Hall: Wizards of the Coast and Star City Games. Both were supporting Magic: The Gathering, and WotC was promoting D&D Insider, as a bridge between one of its core product lines and the techie theme of the Expo itself. Most of the companies in the Expo Hall were computer manufacturers and video game companies. Again, this stuff is not my forte, but I did my best to represent the Cave. I started by checking out some of the smaller indie game publishers from the Boston metro area, who had a special area set aside for them.

  • Dejobaan Games was pushing Aaaaa!, a game where you score points by engaging in all sorts of silly behavior while falling off a skyscraper.
  • Binary Takeover was demo'ing Turba, a tile-based puzzler where the behavior of the tiles is partially controlled by the music you are listening to on your computer – you see, Turba is partially an MP3 player (there's a good chance you'll see at least a capsule review here on OgreCave at some point).
  • The Singapore-MIT GAMBIT game lab had a variety of educational games and experimental game AI implementations. I've guest lectured for an afternoon at MIT on game design theory, so I had to return the favor by plugging them, since they're that little college right up the street from where I went. :-)

Surfacescapes at PAX EastOther than two local game stores (The Compleat Strategist and Pandemonium Books and Games), the last exhibitors in the tabletop gaming areas that I spent time with were graduate students from Carnegie Mellon University. They were showing off demos of how Microsoft's Surface Table, an infrared-sensitive table, could be used as a partially-automated DM tool to play Dungeons & Dragons: Fourth Edition. Their project is called Surfacescapes, a tremendous feat of computer engineering, both on the part of Microsoft and the students at CMU. For now, I will let you check out their website, but I hope that we can get them on a future OgreCave Audio Report episode or Gaming News Update to let you hear more about them.

I'd like to give a real shout out to Phil Reed and the good folks at Steve Jackson Games for introducing me to their newer products. While Cthulhu Dice had so little strategy that it wasn't my cup of tea, Zombie Dice was quite fun as a light, filler, press-your-luck game. Revolution! is the first Euro-style game I've seen out of Steve Jackson Games – it had great components and was a blast to play. I was helping to test out a proposed expansion for the game; the expansion is slated for later this year if some print buying questions can be answered. I will have to hold off on commenting on how the base game plays with three or four, but I played the six-player game with the expansion, and it was the most fun that I had playing a game at PAX East, even including popular games like Dominion. I normally don't do this, but I went out and bought a copy of the game immediately after I'd played it. It was that fun, and SJG can quote me on that.

I want to extend my heartfelt thanks to all of the exhibitors in the tabletop gaming area, because, feeling like a fish out of water, I hovered around the familiar hobby games, chatted a lot, and asked a lot of questions. Part of the reason I love hobby gaming is the people, and these exhibitors really showed the fun, friendly, high caliber of people that made me glad that I attended PAX East. Given the lower traffic of the hobby gaming area, I got to spend quality time demo'ing games in a way that I might not have at a dedicated hobby gaming convention.

Plugging in
OK, next, being a board gamer, I tried to find something familiar in this sea of video games. I play a handful of PC games, and Hudson Soft looked familiar. I checked out their game Rooms: The Main Building. This is available on the PC already, and it's being ported over to the Wii and the Nintendo DS. Remember those 15-piece sliding puzzle games – you move tiles to the empty space to slide yet more things around to eventually form a picture? That's Rooms, only you play a little person trapped inside one of those puzzles, who must navigate them like they are individual rooms. You try to push the rooms around to form a complete picture so that you can escape. This concept appealed to me, so I may try the demo on the PC. The Wii version was not for me, though – I have decent hand-eye coordination, but I sometimes have microtremors in my hands. So, I can do martial arts, but if I tried to be a brain surgeon I'd lobotomize you accidentally about 90% of the time. Trying to point the Wii at the tiny arrows in rooms was very frustrating for me. The Nintendo DS version was more approachable, but too small for my mediocre vision. Still, I think the game looks quite appealing.

Next, I'm a comic geek from back in the day, so I looked for things at the show that were comic themed. Twisted Pixel gave a first glimpse of Comic Jumper: The Adventures of Captain Smiley. It was like a very violent Saturday morning cartoon – it had an Earthworm Jim vibe in terms of the art style (showing my aged Sega Genesis cred there, huh?). Ska Studios had The Dishwasher: Vampire Smile and Charlie Murder. Both games had a gritty indie web comic vibe to them that drew me in for a closer look. The former was a 2D action platformer, and the publisher describes the latter as a "four-player arcade beat 'em up featuring all four members of the revolutionary punk act who are on a crusade to retrieve front man Charlie Murder's girlfriend, Skelekitten, from their chart topping metal rivals."

While I didn't see the new City of Heroes when I was in the Expo Hall, the new Going Rogue expansion was talked about extensively at a Paragon Studios panel I attended, and I saw some sample footage from the game. It was impressive if you are into things superheroic. Going Rogue will allow you to convert your experienced character from good to evil, or vice versa, in the City of Heroes world. You have to go from good, to vigilante, to evil, or from evil, to rogue, to good, over time. Paragon also showed their upcoming Ultra Mode that really improves the shadows, reflections, and all manner of texturing in the City of Heroes world – definitely things to be excited about if you are into that game.

Dante's Inferno at PAX EastThe Valentine award for the brand new game that feels old school goes to Electronic Arts' Dante's Inferno. The imagery was literally hellish, and was disturbingly sexually lurid. This is a first person fantasy hack-and-slasher whose gameplay is like a cross between Chakan: The Forever Man and Rastan (showing my age yet?). You needed to be highly caffeinated and have fantastic hand-eye coordination to survive this one. The theme seemed to be that your lost love has been dragged to hell and you need to save her. Nobody was explaining the game, but I think I saw one bare-chested succubus that had a scorpion's tail for a penis, and another giant she-demon was using her breast milk to produce little angry demon children. Yes, if you were looking for your acid trip, you found it.

The best sequel to an old classic was Prince of Persia: The Forgotten Sands. This incarnation has all the acrobatic exploration and time freezing of its fathers before it, but this time with the ability to manipulate the elements. These time powers give the game an added puzzle element that one-ups the "I must press the 'B' button now" feel of the ancestors to this game.

Swag was being given away at the booth for Red Dead Redemption, creating longer lines than I would tolerate to play it, so I'm limited to reporting on the demo footage. This caught my eye as probably the most immersive looking game in the Expo Hall. In this Western-themed video game, you ride horses off into the sunset, chase down outlaws, play games where you stab your Bowie knife between your fingers at high speed, and there might have even been some poker, though I can't verify the last one. It was gorgeous.

On the cutting edge tech front were NVIDIA and IMMERZ. NVIDIA was pimping their 3D glasses and multiple-monitor gaming experience. Usable with hundreds of Direct X titles (many military games and first-person shooters), particularly with the multiple monitor setup, the NVIDIA PC upgrade kit gave a very good since of depth, while the multiple monitor system seemed to give you 90 to 120 degrees of perception if you can tolerate the monitor bezels/frames dividing up that field a bit. IMMERZ had a Kinetic Omni-Directional Resonance machine, a harness that analyzed the audio tracks of your games and sent sonic vibrations into your chest. The plug-n-play version was not really doing a lot for me; it felt like a set of joy buzzers attached to my chest. The exhibitors assured me that products specifically designed to take advantage of the technology produce even more realistic kinetic simulations. It sounds like they intend to port this product over to movie theaters to give you a kinetic as well as audio experience. Having experienced the "butt kickers" at IMAX theaters, I found the IMMERZ technology to be lacking, but then again, maybe I wasn't using it with the right video game for the proper experience. Since the technology has already won some industry acclaim, what do I know?

While many of you are probably up on things concerning the video-music gaming experience, particularly Guitar Hero and Rock Band, I figure I should tell you about a pair of the more interesting add-ons I saw at the show. OpenChord.org was showing off some hardware in development to create guitars that you could actually play chords on that would work with video game software. The code was open source. The product looked only at proof of concept stage, but I didn't have time to conduct an interview. PowerGig was a new, actual six-string electric guitar with a wireless control system that allows it to be used either with the PowerGig kit coming out around November of this year or with games like Rock Band. When used with its native software, this game is designed to teach you how to play an electric guitar and jam out, not just hit the A & B buttons on a fake guitar. The guitar was there; the software and drum kit was not.

Other Attractions
Geek Chic table at PAX EastLastly, on the Expo Hall side of things, is couch potato gear and gaming furniture. PlayOn is a new software product that will allow you to watch streaming Hulu, Netflix, CBS, Major League Baseball, and other media providers directly on your Xbox, PS3, or Wii. Geek Chic was showing off their absolutely opulent role-playing and board gaming tables. If you've got thousands of dollars and want to blow it on the most ridiculous gaming table imaginable, complete with fold-away writing desks and cup holder, then check out Geek Chic.

Being the 37-year old (almost 38-year old) gamer geek that I am, I felt obliged to spend some time in the classic arcade that PAX East had on display, courtesy of New England's own American Classic Arcade Museum. It was a real treat to walk in there, not having been in a real arcade in some years. Most amusing was watching player after player die within seconds playing Dragon's Lair, the old Don Bluth animated laserdisc video game system. It's still as impossible to day on free play as it was back in the day with a pocket chock full of quarters. My regret is that I didn't wait in line to play Galaga, one of my favorite arcade classics.

Wrapping up
Well, as I've cleared the typical 2500+ words that I normally type for feature length reviews, I'm going to have to close out my PAX East report. Hopefully this has given you some feel for the show and its contents.

Deputy Ogre Lee Valentine signing off.

P.S. Maybe someday with all my reporting I'll grow up to be a real Ogre, but for now I'm just glad that I'm six feet tall and not classified as a Kua-Toa like poor Steve. Hah. :-)


Have something to add? Leave your comments here.


Back to Features index

Site copyright 2001-2010 Allan Sugarbaker. Trademarks/copyrights mentioned are owned by their respective owners.